IQ and Autism! Are they valid and reliable?
Many assessments, especially in schools, rely heavily on IQ tests (tests of intelligence). Often, the child gets a secondary diagnosis of cognitive impairment, in addition to autism. Or, the child may be diagnosed as intellectually impaired, but not autism.
Unfortunately, intelligence testing is often very unreliable with children with autism. The scores are frequently much lower than their true cognitive abilities. There are many factors for this. People on the spectrum often have complex processing problems, including sensory processing issues, auditory processing problems, and delayed information processing. These processing issues interfere significantly with being able to understand what is expected, respond to verbal questions/directions, and interpret the intent of the questions. People on the spectrum often have verbal communication problems (both receptively and expressively), while many of these tests rely heavily on auditory processing and verbal skills. Also, these tests require socially regulating, face to face with an examiner, which is often extremely difficult for children on the spectrum.
In addition, task performance anxiety for many on the spectrum is very high in situations that put them socially on the spot. They tend to freeze and panic under such conditions, or misinterpret what the examiner is expecting. Added to these are the problems with attention, hyper-focusing on detail or being very distracted, which will significantly interfere with task performance. Lastly, many children on the spectrum have behavior interference in the form of repetitive, stereotypic behavior, which often increases under pressure. With all these conflicting variables, the chances of getting an accurate read for people with autism is unlikely.
Given the many variables autism creates for intelligence testing for children on the spectrum, please be very careful in interpreting these results; especially when making diagnostic decisions from them. They historically underestimate the child’s true cognitive abilities, resulting in misdiagnosis of cognitive impairments, misplacement in schools, and lower expectations for them cognitively and adaptively. Often these children have higher scores on the nonverbal sections and lower scores on the verbal sections for children with autism. Children with Aspergers may show the opposite with high verbal scores, but lower nonverbal scores. In conclusion, the more severely impaired the autism, the more unreliable intelligence testing is. If testing is needed for those with autism, try and use a nonverbal test like the Leiter International Performance Scale, or the Raven Progressive Matrices Test. However, even with these, be suspicious if your child’s results are low. If your child has communication and processing problems, there is a greater possibility the scores are suppressed. Be very suspicious of the intellectual impairment label. There is a good chance that it does not accurately reflect your child. The tests do not match the processing, communication, and learning style of your child.
Since this article was written the WAIS intelligent scale has built in measurements for working memory and processing speed, both of which helps the validity of testing people on the spectrum. However, with the sensory and auditory processing difficulties of many on the spectrum these results are still a misrepresentation of abilities. Thanks.
Many assessments, especially in schools, rely heavily on IQ tests (tests of intelligence). Often, the child gets a secondary diagnosis of cognitive impairment, in addition to autism. Or, the child may be diagnosed as intellectually impaired, but not autism.
Unfortunately, intelligence testing is often very unreliable with children with autism. The scores are frequently much lower than their true cognitive abilities. There are many factors for this. People on the spectrum often have complex processing problems, including sensory processing issues, auditory processing problems, and delayed information processing. These processing issues interfere significantly with being able to understand what is expected, respond to verbal questions/directions, and interpret the intent of the questions. People on the spectrum often have verbal communication problems (both receptively and expressively), while many of these tests rely heavily on auditory processing and verbal skills. Also, these tests require socially regulating, face to face with an examiner, which is often extremely difficult for children on the spectrum.
In addition, task performance anxiety for many on the spectrum is very high in situations that put them socially on the spot. They tend to freeze and panic under such conditions, or misinterpret what the examiner is expecting. Added to these are the problems with attention, hyper-focusing on detail or being very distracted, which will significantly interfere with task performance. Lastly, many children on the spectrum have behavior interference in the form of repetitive, stereotypic behavior, which often increases under pressure. With all these conflicting variables, the chances of getting an accurate read for people with autism is unlikely.
Given the many variables autism creates for intelligence testing for children on the spectrum, please be very careful in interpreting these results; especially when making diagnostic decisions from them. They historically underestimate the child’s true cognitive abilities, resulting in misdiagnosis of cognitive impairments, misplacement in schools, and lower expectations for them cognitively and adaptively. Often these children have higher scores on the nonverbal sections and lower scores on the verbal sections for children with autism. Children with Aspergers may show the opposite with high verbal scores, but lower nonverbal scores. In conclusion, the more severely impaired the autism, the more unreliable intelligence testing is. If testing is needed for those with autism, try and use a nonverbal test like the Leiter International Performance Scale, or the Raven Progressive Matrices Test. However, even with these, be suspicious if your child’s results are low. If your child has communication and processing problems, there is a greater possibility the scores are suppressed. Be very suspicious of the intellectual impairment label. There is a good chance that it does not accurately reflect your child. The tests do not match the processing, communication, and learning style of your child.
Since this article was written the WAIS intelligent scale has built in measurements for working memory and processing speed, both of which helps the validity of testing people on the spectrum. However, with the sensory and auditory processing difficulties of many on the spectrum these results are still a misrepresentation of abilities. Thanks.